CO129-231 - Acting Governor Marsh - 1887 [1-3] — Page 160

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

efficient deterrent and reformatory Gaol discipline can be established on a firm basis.

As the building of a new Gaol seems unlikely to be undertaken for some time, I can only repeat my suggestion of last year that short sentence prisoners, that is, men sentenced to 6 months and under, should be removed to some other building, or perhaps to a hulk; this would leave space enough in Victoria Gaol to accommodate long sentence prisoners on the separate system, and also give more space for industrial work.

34. I would also repeat my suggestion that habitual criminals and others who have earned remission of sentence should be placed by legislative enactment (as in England) under Police supervision, so that, if found returning to a criminal career, they might at once be sent back by the Magistrates to prison.

35. While the Gaol is as now so greatly overcrowded, I think the Government might take into consideration the case of the large number of prisoners mostly belonging to the criminal classes who are confined for want of finding security for good behaviour. I am not allowed to make these men work. They are well fed and live comfortably in associated idleness. I brought this subject to notice in paragraph 21 of my Report for 1885. I am sorry to say, I believe many of these men rather like their sentence and will not find security even when able to do so. And it seems an incongruity that while honest destitutes who are provided with food and lodging in Gaol are compelled to do a daily task of work, the criminal security men are freed from the obligation of performing any labour whatever beyond cleaning their own cells. 479 men were imprisoned during the year for want of finding security.

36. The overcrowding of the Gaol might also be to some extent reduced, if other punishment than imprisonment could be found for the persons now imprisoned for gambling. 399 men have been committed to prison for this offence during the year. The great majority of these men do not belong to the criminal classes. They are mostly hard-working men, rice pounders, and coal porters. They overcrowd the Gaol; they are neither deterred from gambling by imprisonment nor are they improved. It is too much to be feared that many of them are deteriorated and corrupted by compulsory and constant association with the criminal classes they meet in Gaol.

(B.)

MONTH 1884 1885 1886 January, February, March, 22 14 April, May, June, 28 16 18 July, 18 15 August, 23 23 September, October, November, 29 32 December, 6 29 Total, 204 Daily average number in Prison, 552 530 674

(C.)

MONTH 1884 1885 1886 January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November, December, Total, 195 270 Daily average number in Prison, 552 530 674

A. GORDON,

Superintendent.

(A.) VICTORIA GAOL.

MONTH 1884 1885 1886 January, 65 74 76 February, 78 28 16 March, 82 14 April, 52 133 11 May, 106 7 June, 60 61 15 July, 52 9 August, 69 47 11 September, 82 17 October, 31 50 23 November, 17 23 17 December, 41 15 21 Total, 719 709 212 Daily average number in Prison, 552 530 674

A. GORDON,

Superintendent.

(D.)

CONVICTION 1885 1886 1st, 32 44 2nd, 24 23 3rd, 31 4th, 70 362 5th, 77 289 6th, 72 344 7th, 50 254 8th, 64 174 9th, 35 148 10th, 43 162 11th, 93 12th, Total, 529 2,132

A. GORDON,

Superintendent.

TOTAL............14) 578

612

A. GORDON,

Superintendent.

158

Edit History

2026-05-25 11:44:15 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
efficient deterrent and reformatory Gaol discipline can be established on a firm basis. As the building of a new Gaol seems unlikely to be undertaken for some time, I can only repeat my suggestion of last year that short sentence prisoners, that is, men sentenced to 6 months and under, should be removed to some other building, or perhaps to a hulk; this would leave space enough in Victoria Gaol to accommodate long sentence prisoners on the separate system, and also give more space for industrial work. 34. I would also repeat my suggestion that habitual criminals and others who have earned remission of sentence should be placed by legislative enactment (as in England) under Police supervision, so that, if found returning to a criminal career, they might at once be sent back by the Magistrates to prison. 35. While the Gaol is as now so greatly overcrowded, I think the Government might take into consideration the case of the large number of prisoners mostly belonging to the criminal classes who are confined for want of finding security for good behaviour. I am not allowed to make these men work. They are well fed and live comfortably in associated idleness. I brought this subject to notice in paragraph 21 of my Report for 1885. I am sorry to say, I believe many of these men rather like their sentence and will not find security even when able to do so. And it seems an incongruity that while honest destitutes who are provided with food and lodging in Gaol are compelled to do a daily task of work, the criminal security men are freed from the obligation of performing any labour whatever beyond cleaning their own cells. 479 men were imprisoned during the year for want of finding security. 36. The overcrowding of the Gaol might also be to some extent reduced, if other punishment than imprisonment could be found for the persons now imprisoned for gambling. 399 men have been committed to prison for this offence during the year. The great majority of these men do not belong to the criminal classes. They are mostly hard-working men, rice pounders, and coal porters. They overcrowd the Gaol; they are neither deterred from gambling by imprisonment nor are they improved. It is too much to be feared that many of them are deteriorated and corrupted by compulsory and constant association with the criminal classes they meet in Gaol. (B.) MONTH 1884 1885 1886 January, February, March, 22 14 April, May, June, 28 16 18 July, 18 15 August, 23 23 September, October, November, 29 32 December, 6 29 Total, 204 Daily average number in Prison, 552 530 674 (C.) MONTH 1884 1885 1886 January, February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, October, November, December, Total, 195 270 Daily average number in Prison, 552 530 674 A. GORDON, Superintendent. (A.) VICTORIA GAOL. MONTH 1884 1885 1886 January, 65 74 76 February, 78 28 16 March, 82 14 April, 52 133 11 May, 106 7 June, 60 61 15 July, 52 9 August, 69 47 11 September, 82 17 October, 31 50 23 November, 17 23 17 December, 41 15 21 Total, 719 709 212 Daily average number in Prison, 552 530 674 A. GORDON, Superintendent. (D.) CONVICTION 1885 1886 1st, 32 44 2nd, 24 23 3rd, 31 4th, 70 362 5th, 77 289 6th, 72 344 7th, 50 254 8th, 64 174 9th, 35 148 10th, 43 162 11th, 93 12th, Total, 529 2,132 A. GORDON, Superintendent. TOTAL............14) 578 612 A. GORDON, Superintendent. 158
Baseline (Original)
? efficient deterrent and reformatory Gaol discipline can be established on a firm basis. As the building of a new Gaol seems unlikely to be undertaken for some time, I can only repeat my suggestion of last year that short sentence prisoners, that is, men sentenced to 6 months and under, should be removed to some other building, or perhaps to a hulk; this would leave space enough in Victoria Gaol to accommodate long sentence prisoners on the separate system, and also give more space for industrial work, 34. I would also repeat my suggestion that habitual criminals and others who have earned remission of sentence should be placed by legislative enactment (as in England) under Police supervision, so that, if found returning to a criminal career, they might at once be sent back by the Magistrates to prison. 35. While the Gaol is as now so greatly overcrowded, I think the Government might take into consideration the case of the large number of prisoners mostly belonging to the criminal classes who are confined for want of finding security for good behaviour. I am not allowed to make these men work. They are well fed and live comfortably in associated idleness. I brought this subject to notice in paragraph 21 of my Report for 1885. I am sorry to say. I believe many of these men rather like their sentence and will not find security even when able to do so. And it seems an incongruity that while honest destitutes who are provided with food and lodging in Gaol are compelled to do a daily task of work, the criminal security men are freed from the obligation of performing any labour whatever beyond cleaning their own cells. 479 men were imprisoned during the year for want of finding security. 36. The overcrowding of the Gaol might also be to some extent reduced, if other punishment than imprisonment could be found for the persons now imprisoned for gambling. 399 men have been committed to prison for this offence during the year. The great majority of these men do not belong to the criminal classes. They are mostly hard-working men, rice pounders, and coal porters. They overcrowd the Gaol; they are neither deterred from gambling by imprisonment nor are they improved. It is too much to be feared that many of them are deteriorated and corrupted by compulsory and constant association with the criminal classes they meet in Gaol. (B.) Return of Offences reported of Prisoners fighting with or assaulting each other, for the years 1884, 1885 and 1886. January, February, March, April, May, Junc, July,. August, September, October, November, December, MONTA. Total,... 1886. 1884. Daily average number 1885. Daily average number Daily average number in Prison, 552. in Prison, 530. în Prison, 674. 22 28 14 16 18 15 23 18 17 26 29 -32 29 6 31 24 22 19 19 27 13 24 18 13 30 12 8 14 18 17 21 મ્ર 9 22 10 7 270 204 (C.) 195 A. GORDON, Superintendent. Return of Offences repórted of Prisoners having Tobacco, for the years 1884, 1885 and 1886. MONTH. 1884. 1885. 1886. in Prison, 552. Daily average number | Daily average number in Prison, 530. Daily average number in Prison, 674. January, February, March, April, May,. June, July,. August, September, October, November, December, (A.) VICTORIA GAOL. Return of Reports for talking, &c., in the years 1884, 1885 and 1886. MONTH. A. GORDON, January, Superintendent. February, March, April, May, June, July, August, September, 1834. 1885. 1886. Daily average number in Prison, 552. Daily average number in Prison, 530. Daily average number in Prison, 674. October,. November, December, Total,.. 65 74 76 78 28 16 82 14 52 133 11 106 7 60 61 15 52 9 69 47 11 82 17 31 50 23 17 41 15 30 39 21 23 719 709 212 A. GORDON, Superintendent. (D.) Comparative Return of Prisoners confined in Victoria Gaol on the 31st December, 1885, and 31st December, 1886, from 1st to 12th Convictions. CONVICTION. 1885. 1886. 14 55 119 17 25 185 ist, 32 44 248 2nd, 24 23 330 3rd, 31 CROSSG 252 197 4th, 70 362 298 5th, 77 289 297 6th, 72 344 232 7th, 50 254 318 8th, 64 174 209 9th, 35 148 183 10th, 43 162 93 11th, 12th, 375 414 41 62 29 35 30 27 28 24 23 18 20 15 16 10 4 1 2 3 4 3 1 Total,. 529 2,132 2,659 A. GORDON, TOTAL............14) 578 612 Superintendent. A. GORDON, Superintendent. 158
2026-05-25 11:44:15 · Baseline
View content

?

efficient deterrent and reformatory Gaol discipline can be established on a firm basis.

As the building of a new Gaol seems unlikely to be undertaken for some time, I can only repeat my suggestion of last year that short sentence prisoners, that is, men sentenced to 6 months and under, should be removed to some other building, or perhaps to a hulk; this would leave space enough in Victoria Gaol to accommodate long sentence prisoners on the separate system, and also give more space for industrial work,

34. I would also repeat my suggestion that habitual criminals and others who have earned remission of sentence should be placed by legislative enactment (as in England) under Police supervision, so that, if found returning to a criminal career, they might at once be sent back by the Magistrates to prison.

35. While the Gaol is as now so greatly overcrowded, I think the Government might take into consideration the case of the large number of prisoners mostly belonging to the criminal classes who are confined for want of finding security for good behaviour. I am not allowed to make these men work. They are well fed and live comfortably in associated idleness. I brought this subject to notice in paragraph 21 of my Report for 1885. I am sorry to say. I believe many of these men rather like their sentence and will not find security even when able to do so. And it seems an incongruity that while honest destitutes who are provided with food and lodging in Gaol are compelled to do a daily task of work, the criminal security men are freed from the obligation of performing any labour whatever beyond cleaning their own cells. 479 men were imprisoned during the year for want of finding security.

36. The overcrowding of the Gaol might also be to some extent reduced, if other punishment than imprisonment could be found for the persons now imprisoned for gambling. 399 men have been committed to prison for this offence during the year. The great majority of these men do not belong to the criminal classes. They are mostly hard-working men, rice pounders, and coal porters. They overcrowd the Gaol; they are neither deterred from gambling by imprisonment nor are they improved. It is too much to be feared that many of them are deteriorated and corrupted by compulsory and constant association with the criminal classes they meet in Gaol.

(B.)

Return of Offences reported of Prisoners fighting with or assaulting each other, for the years 1884, 1885 and 1886.

January, February, March,

April, May, Junc,

July,.

August,

September, October, November, December,

MONTA.

Total,...

1886.

1884.

Daily average number

1885. Daily average number

Daily average number

in Prison, 552.

in Prison, 530.

în Prison, 674.

22

28

14

16

18

15

23

18

17

26

29

-32

29

6

31

24

22

19

19

27

13

24

18

13

30

12

8

14

18

17

21

મ્ર

9

22

10

7

270

204

(C.)

195

A. GORDON,

Superintendent.

Return of Offences repórted of Prisoners having Tobacco, for the years 1884, 1885 and 1886.

MONTH.

1884.

1885.

1886.

in Prison, 552.

Daily average number | Daily average number

in Prison, 530.

Daily average number

in Prison, 674.

January,

February,

March,

April,

May,.

June,

July,.

August,

September,

October,

November,

December,

(A.)

VICTORIA GAOL.

Return of Reports for talking, &c., in the years 1884, 1885 and 1886.

MONTH.

A. GORDON,

January,

Superintendent.

February,

March,

April,

May,

June,

July,

August,

September,

1834.

1885.

1886.

Daily average number in Prison, 552.

Daily average number in Prison, 530.

Daily average number

in Prison, 674.

October,.

November,

December,

Total,..

65

74

76

78

28 16

82

14

52

133

11

106

7

60

61

15

52

9

69

47

11

82

17

31

50

23

17

41

15

30

39

21

23

719

709

212

A. GORDON,

Superintendent.

(D.)

Comparative Return of Prisoners confined in Victoria Gaol on the 31st December, 1885, and 31st December, 1886, from 1st to 12th Convictions.

CONVICTION.

1885.

1886.

14

55

119

17

25

185

ist,

32

44

248

2nd,

24

23

330

3rd,

31

CROSSG

252

197

4th,

70

362

298

5th,

77

289

297

6th,

72

344

232

7th,

50

254

318

8th,

64

174

209

9th,

35

148

183

10th,

43

162

93

11th,

12th,

375

414

41

62

29

35

30

27

28

24

23

18

20

15

16

10

4

1

2

3

4

3

1

Total,.

529

2,132

2,659

A. GORDON,

TOTAL............14)

578

612

Superintendent.

A. GORDON,

Superintendent.

158

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.